Worried Your Insurance Will Go Up After an Accident in California?
After a car accident, you already have a lot to deal with — injuries, car repairs, and stress. On top of that, many people start worrying about one thing:
👉 “Will my car insurance go up if I file a claim?”
This is a very common concern in California.
The good news is — your insurance rate does not automatically go up just because you file a claim.
There are specific rules in California that decide when your premium can increase. Once you understand how it works, it becomes much easier to make the right decisions after an accident.
Featured
On
Do Insurance Rates Always Increase After an Accident Claim in California?
No, they don’t.
A lot of people think that the moment they file an accident claim, their insurance will go up. But that’s not how it works in California.
Insurance companies cannot raise your premium just because you:
- Filed a claim
- Reported an accident
- Asked for compensation
What really matters is who was at fault and your overall driving record.
So if the accident was not your fault, there’s a good chance your rates will stay the same.
What Actually Affects Your Car Insurance Rates in California?
In California, insurance companies must follow certain rules when setting your premium. These rules come from consumer protection laws, including Proposition 103, which was created to keep insurance pricing fair.
Your rate mainly depends on three things:
1. Your Driving Record
This is the biggest factor.
If you have:
- At-fault accidents
- Traffic violations like speeding or running a red light
2. How Much You Drive
The more you drive, the higher the risk.
Insurance companies look at:
- Annual mileage
- How often you use your car
3. Your Driving Experience
This includes how long you’ve been driving.
Drivers with more experience are usually seen as safer, which can help keep insurance costs lower.
When Can Your Insurance Rate Go Up After an Accident?
Your rate may go up only if you are considered mostly responsible for the accident.
In California, that usually means:
👉 You are 51% or more at fault
This is often called being “principally at fault.”
If that applies to you, then your insurance company may increase your premium.
What Does “Principally At Fault” Mean in Simple Terms?
It simply means you were the main reason the accident happened.
Not just a small mistake — but the biggest cause of the crash.
For example:
- Running a red light
- Speeding and hitting another vehicle
- Not yielding when required
In situations like these, your insurance rate may increase.
Situations Where Your Rate Should Stay the Same
There are many situations where your insurance rate should stay the same, even if you file a claim. Here are some common examples:
- Your Car Was Parked
If your car was parked properly and someone hit it, it is not your fault. You were not even driving at that time. In this case, your insurance should not go up because you did nothing wrong.
- You Were Rear-Ended
If another driver hits your car from behind, it is usually their fault. You were driving normally, and they failed to stop in time. Because of this, your insurance rate should stay the same.
- Another Driver Was Clearly at Fault
If the other driver broke traffic rules, like running a red light or speeding, they are responsible for the accident. If there is proof like a police report, your insurance should not increase.
- Hit-and-Run Accidents
If someone hits your car and runs away, it is not your fault. Just make sure you report it to the police and your insurance company. In this case, your rate should not go up.
- Accidents Caused by Outside Factors
Sometimes accidents happen because of things you cannot control. For example, hitting an animal, something falling on your car, or bad road conditions. These are not your mistakes, so your insurance should not increase.
- Emergency Situations
If you were dealing with an emergency and an accident happened, it may not be counted against you. In many cases, your insurance company will not raise your rate in this situation.
What Happens If Both Drivers Share Fault?
California follows something called a comparative fault system.
That means:
- More than one person can share responsibility
- You can still file a claim even if you were partly at fault
But here’s the important part:
👉 Your insurance usually increases only if you are more than 50% responsible
If your fault is less than that, your premium may not change.
Will Filing a Claim Alone Raise Your Insurance?
No, it won’t.
Just filing a claim does not increase your rate.
You have every right to:
- Report an accident
- File a claim
- Get compensation
Without being penalized just for doing so.
This applies to:
- Car damage claims
- Injury claims
- Uninsured motorist claims
Understanding Uninsured and Underinsured Coverage
If the other driver doesn’t have enough insurance, you may need to use your own policy to cover your losses. This situation is more common than many people think, especially in serious accidents where damages are high.
This is called:
- UM (Uninsured Motorist)
- UIM (Underinsured Motorist)
These coverages are designed to protect you when the other driver cannot fully pay for your injuries or damages. They help make sure you are not left paying out of your own pocket for something that was not your fault.
In most cases, your rate should not increase if:
- You were not at fault
This type of coverage exists to support you during difficult situations. It is meant to provide financial protection and peace of mind, not to punish you for using your own policy when needed.
Why Some People Avoid Filing Claims (And Why That Can Backfire)
Many people hesitate to file a claim because they are worried their insurance premium will increase. This fear is very common, especially after hearing stories from others.
But avoiding a claim can sometimes lead to bigger financial problems, such as:
- Paying medical bills yourself – Treatment costs can add up quickly, even for minor injuries.
- Covering car repairs out of pocket – Vehicle damage can be expensive without insurance support.
- Losing money you could have recovered – You may miss out on compensation you are legally allowed to claim.
If the accident was not your fault, choosing not to file a claim can actually put more pressure on you financially. In many cases, using your insurance properly is the smarter and safer option.
When Insurance Rates Might Still Increase
There are certain situations where your insurance premium may go up after an accident. This usually depends on your level of responsibility and overall driving history.
Some common reasons include:
- You caused the accident – If you are found mostly at fault, your insurer may see you as a higher risk driver.
- You have multiple traffic violations – Repeated tickets or violations can impact your safety record.
- You’ve had several claims in the past – A history of frequent claims may lead to higher premiums.
- Your driving history shows higher risk – Insurance companies look at patterns, not just one incident.
It’s important to understand that one single event does not always lead to an increase. Insurers usually consider the bigger picture before making any changes.
How Insurance Companies Decide Your New Rate
Insurance companies use different factors to decide whether your premium should change after a claim. They follow a structured process based on your driving and claim history.
They usually look at:
- Fault percentage – Whether you were fully or partially responsible for the accident.
- Driving history – Past violations or accidents over a certain period.
- Claim history – How many claims you have filed before.
- Overall risk level – Your profile as a driver based on multiple factors.
All of this information helps them decide if your risk level has increased. However, they still must follow California laws, which means they cannot raise your rates without a valid and fair reason.
How to Protect Yourself After an Accident
Taking the right steps after an accident can help protect both your claim and your insurance record.
Here’s what you should do:
Report the Accident Clearly
Share only basic facts like time, location, and what happened. Avoid guessing or adding details you are not sure about. Even small mistakes in your statement can be used later against you.
Collect Evidence
Take clear photos and videos of the vehicles, road conditions, and any visible injuries. Try to gather names and contact details of witnesses, as their statements can support your side if there is a dispute.
Get a Police Report
Always try to get an official police report, even for smaller accidents. It creates a neutral record of what happened and can be very helpful if the other driver changes their story later.
Seek Medical Attention
Visit a doctor as soon as possible, even if you feel fine at first. Some injuries take time to show symptoms, and early medical records help connect your injuries to the accident.
Keep All Records
Save everything related to the accident, including medical bills, repair estimates, prescriptions, and any communication. These documents help show the real impact of the accident on your life.
Don’t Assume Fault
Do not admit fault or apologize at the scene, even if you feel unsure. Let the insurance companies and investigation process decide who is responsible based on evidence.
Should You Be Afraid to File a Claim?
No — especially if the accident was not your fault.
California law is designed to protect drivers from unfair insurance increases.
If you avoid filing a claim out of fear, you could:
- Lose compensation
- Delay your recovery
- Pay unnecessary costs
Why the Right Support Matters
Dealing with insurance after an accident can feel confusing.
Insurance companies handle claims every day — but for most people, this is new.
Getting the right guidance can help you:
- Understand your situation
- Avoid common mistakes
- Know what your claim is worth
- Handle things with more confidence
In many cases, it can make a real difference in the final outcome.
Speak With Someone Who Understands the Process
If you’re unsure about filing a claim or worried about your insurance going up, it’s always better to get clear answers first.
At The LA Law Firm, we help people understand:
- How accident claims work
- When insurance rates increase
- What steps to take next
📞 Contact us today for a free consultation
CALL TODAY FOR A FREE CONSULTATION
- Get your car fixed.
- Get a rental.
- Get medical assistance
- We offer medical transportation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will my insurance go up if the accident was not my fault?
In most cases, your insurance rate should not increase if you were not at fault. California law focuses on your driving record, not just the fact that a claim was filed. Still, it’s a good idea to check your policy details to be sure.
Does filing a claim automatically increase insurance?
No, simply filing a claim does not automatically raise your premium. Insurance companies mainly look at fault and your overall driving history. If you were not responsible, your rate may stay the same.
What does being 51% at fault mean?
Being 51% at fault means you were considered the main cause of the accident. In California, this is the point where insurance companies may treat you as responsible. This can lead to an increase in your insurance premium.
Will a minor accident affect my premium?
Even a small accident can affect your premium if you are found to be mostly at fault. Insurance companies still consider it part of your driving record. If you are not responsible, the impact is usually much lower or none.
What if both drivers share fault?
When both drivers share fault, the percentage of responsibility matters. Your rate may increase only if your share of fault is more than 50%. If it’s less, it may not have a major impact.
Do hit-and-run accidents increase insurance rates?
If you are not at fault and report the hit-and-run properly, your rates usually should not go up. Reporting it quickly and providing evidence helps protect your record. Always file a police report in these cases.
Can I challenge an insurance rate increase?
Yes, you have the right to question any increase in your insurance premium. You can contact your insurance company and ask how they calculated it. If something seems wrong, you can request a review or clarification.
Do multiple claims affect insurance rates?
Yes, filing multiple claims over time can lead to higher premiums, especially if you were at fault. Insurance companies may see this as a higher risk. Keeping a clean driving record helps maintain lower rates.
CALL TODAY FOR A FREE CONSULTATION
- we make the retainer process simple and swift. After completing a short application questionaire, we provide you with a full overview of your case and take over conversations with all insurance companies and other parties—so you can focus on your medical recovery